Janie’s Worldview compared to a Christian’s Worldview
By: Peter Mayhew
The worldview portrayed in any novel is of utmost importance in order to understand the theme of the novel. As well, as a Christian, it is important to evaluate the worldview in order to be shrewd in discerning what is applicable in literature to our lives and what is useful only in understanding a non Christian perspective. In Zora Hurston’s Their Eyes were Watching God, Janie’s worldview through most of the novel is naturalistic. She responds to the situations in her life as if what she can see and feel physically and emotionally is all there is. However, Janie cannot be neatly classified in this category because she also believes that there is a God. She views God as an all powerful yet disinterested deity. Janie’s worldview cannot be the same as the Christian worldview in this regard. As well, there is almost no reference to Jesus throughout the novel. As a Christian, my personal worldview is based in the Bible. My entire life is part of God’s larger plan, and Jesus is my only savior. It is extremely beneficial to compare Janie’s worldview to that of the Christian. By looking at the answers to the questions of life presented by each worldview, a comparison can be drawn between the two.
The first question that bears answering is “who am I?” Janie begins her story to Pheoby by retelling her early life (10-24). The most important event in that childhood was her coming into womanhood. At this point, Janie’s worldview began to be developed. Although initially she rejects the title of woman (15), eventually she accepts it as the fundamental part of her identity (30). As Christians, people see themselves not in view of who they are, but in view of what Christ has made them. Jesus has sacrificed himself on a cross in order to give Christians the right to be called children of God. Therefore Christians see themselves as adopted heirs to God’s kingdom.
Another question answered by worldviews is “where did I come from?” Janie never really addresses this question. However, when she describes her early life to Pheoby, Janie relates how she was born illegitimately and was raised by her grandmother (23). Although there is no direct reference to the worldview question, from references to God and Janie’s birth story we can assume that Janie probably believed that God did allow for her creation but did not care much about it. The Christian believes that he or she was created in the image of God. Although the circumstances of his or her birth may be difficult or embarrassing, God still places a high value on the life of the individual.
One of the most important questions a person can ask about life is “where am I going?” Janie struggles with this question often throughout the novel. Early on, she despairs, thinking that she will not be able to go anywhere with her marriage (26-30). Later, she finds a way out by running off with Joe. She believes that she has found a path her life can follow. (35 and 38-39). This dream turns sour when she realizes that Joe is more concerned with his own image than loving her. Finally, Janie seems to come to the conclusion that worrying about the future is irrelevant and living in the present is what is important. When she marries Tea Cake, she lives this way and enjoys it, as evident by her allowing Tea Cake to gamble her money (148) moving to the Everglades (151) and relating the story to Pheoby (226). In regards to the little said about Janie’s beliefs regarding death, she does believe in a heaven because she looks forward to hearing Tea Cake’s songs again (222). Christians firmly believe that based on a person’s relationship to Jesus he or she will go either to heaven or hell. Since all have sinned, the default destination is hell. However, through Jesus gift of salvation, people who believe and repent can live with God for eternity.
One other important question is “what is true and what is false?” To Janie the only unwavering truth is her dream of love. As Hurston open’s her story she describes a woman’s tenacity in pursuing the dream of love (1). Janie compares all of her relationships to the standard oh her dream of love which began at the pear tree in her grandmother’s yard (13). Christians also have one standard of truth; however, it is not a girlish dream of love. It is the Word of God. In the Bible, Christians find the ultimate standard for their lives. If uncertain whether a thought process is true or not, Christians can turn to the Bible for guidance.
One of the dilemmas Janie faced was how to I conduct her life. Her Grandmother told her she should search for an important husband who could support her (18). Joe Starks said she should act prim and proper, evident by his refusal to let Janie do anything common (71). Janie rejects all of these opinions and forges her own. She spends her life searching for the love revealed to her in her revelation at the pear tree. Once she finds that love in Tea Cake, she embraces it and lives life to the fullest with Tea Cake. As a Christian, one must conduct his or her life in full obedience to God. Not in order to earn salvation, but in order to praise and worship God.
The last and most important part of a worldview is whether the person believes in a god and how to respond to that god. Janie definitely does believe in a god. Sparingly throughout the book references are made to the Christian God. However, many of the characteristics of the Christian God are absent. For instance, during the hurricane, God is portrayed as whimsically terrorizing humanity (187 and 197). As well, the only times God is mentioned are times of great distress in Janie’s life. Although Janie believes there is a god, she only turns to him when she needs help beyond her abilities. The God of the Bible is far different from Janie’s interpretation. He is all powerful, but he is also loving. He desires a personal relationship with each individual person. A Christian responds to Him by welcoming Him into their lives and placing Him as king of their lives.
By inspecting Janie’s worldview and comparing it to the Christian worldview, the novel becomes much easier to understand. Janie’s actions make more sense. Even more importantly than understanding the book is the knowledge gained with regard to the way people think in the real world. Unfortunately, Janie’s worldview is a very realistic one; countless people believe in an impersonal god. They rely on themselves completely instead of turning to their Creator. Although Janie’s worldview is not something Christians should attempt to imitate, by understanding it Christian can humbly apply that knowledge in witnessing when they meet someone who shares her view.
Works Cited
Hurston, Zora. Their Eyes were Watching God. New York: HarperCollins Publishers Inc., 2000